Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sonny Morton, MD's avatar

I think your conclusion re the education establishment is solid. The same conclusion can be applied to many other fields that are governed by experts. Law, criminal justice, climate science and economics come immediately to mind. You've shown here how this tendency has been with us for a long time. To me, this indicates an innate human tendency to defer to experts.

How to prevent such outcomes? Since trying to change human nature is generally futile and the law of unintended consequences always lurks, I favor the libertarian philosophy of limiting the ability of those who would use force to enact their grand schemes. Take away their ability to use (government) force; require them to use persuasion. The A.G. Bell tale shows us that even without a great deal of force bad ideas can become practice. But at least we have a fighting chance to resist the experts. To the relevance of this discussion to education, my conclusion speaks to the need for school choice so that decisions about how to educate can be made free of force.

Expand full comment
Robert F. Graboyes's avatar

Ahhhhhh! I’ll fix that.

Expand full comment
24 more comments...

No posts